These industries have the highest retention rates for work permit holders who become permanent residents

Janice Rodrigues
Published: November 28, 2024

The healthcare and social assistance sectors had the highest retention rates of temporary foreign workers (TFWs) who become permanent residents, according to a new report by Statistics Canada.

The study by Stats Can found that the retention rate—the percentage of TFWs who remained working in the same sector after having received permanent residency (PR)—varied dramatically across sectors.

Schedule a Free Work Permit Consultation with the Cohen Immigration Law Firm

Which industries had the highest retention rates?

The below table shows the percentage of TFWs who remained working in the same sector after receiving PR during the years 2011-2015, for the industries with the highest retention rates.

IndustryPercentage of workers who remained in the industry one year after receiving PRPercentage of workers who remained in the industry five years after receiving PR
Healthcare and social assistance81.4%64.9%
Utilities80.3%58%
Finance and insurance77.1%55.2%
Public administration72%51.2%
Transportation and warehousing70.4%49%
Manufacturing74%48.9%
Construction70%47.3%

Which industries had the lowest retention rates?

Some industries had significantly lower retention rates, as shown in the table below:

IndustryPercentage of workers who remained in the industry one year after receiving PRPercentage of workers who remained in the industry five years after receiving PR
Management of companies and enterprises36.7%8.7%
Real estate, rental and leasing46.2%19.4%
Other services45.5%20%
Administrative and support, waste management and remediation services54.3%21%
Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting52.8%24.1%

Why is the retention rate important?

Industry retention is important because PR is often granted on the basis of occupation, which is linked to meeting labour market needs.

Having workers remain in such industries is important to alleviate labour shortages in specific sectors and regions.

Industry retention is also more efficient for both businesses and individuals, as less resources are wasted on retraining.

Why do workers change industries?

Factors that could lead workers to change industries include:

  • Wage levels;
  • Working conditions;
  • Job stability; and
  • Specific skill requirements.

Industry retention rates tend to be higher among more engaged employees, so a low retention rate could indicate lesser satisfaction among workers.

What was the overall retention rate?

The study found that 68.4% of TFWs remained in the same sector where they worked as work permit holders, a year after becoming permanent residents.

This fell to 43% for TFWs in the same industry five years after getting their PR.

How does the work permit program affect the retention rate?

There was a big difference in industry retention rates according to work permit programs.

To break it down, the highest retention rates could be found from higher-skilled temporary foreign worker program participants (53.4%), and intra company transferees (51.4%).

Those from the live-in caregiver program had the lowest retention rate by year five of getting their PR (28.6%).

How was the study conducted?

The study looked at TFWs who held paid employment as work permit holders for work purposes (WPPRs), and made the transition to PR between 2011-2015.

Reasons that individuals are showed to have moved out of the industry included

  • shifting to another industry;
  • starting their own business (becoming self-employed);
  • being unemployed; or
  • not appearing in tax records.

Schedule a Free Work Permit Consultation with the Cohen Immigration Law Firm

 

Share this article
Share your voice
Did you find this article helpful?
Thank you for your feedback.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Did you find this article helpful?
Please provide a response
Thank you for your helpful feedback
Please contact us if you would like to share additional feedback, have a question, or would like Canadian immigration assistance.
  • Do you need Canadian immigration assistance? Contact the Contact Cohen Immigration Law firm by completing our form
  • Send us your feedback or your non-legal assistance questions by emailing us at media@canadavisa.com
Related articles
Report identifies occupations set for salary increases in Canada in 2025
Diverse employees celebrate by throwing money in the air.
These industries have the highest retention rates for work permit holders who become permanent residents
A hand holding a briefcase
CRA to hold webinar for international students
Money and income tax papers litter a surface, in a menagerie of financial ministration.
International students in Canada can work 24 hours a week off-campus
A young woman walks while carrying a laptop
Top Stories
What does an immigration representative do?
British Columbia and Alberta issue invitations in new PNP draws
Are you eligible to sponsor your spouse or partner for Canadian immigration?
Join our free newsletter. Get Canada's top immigration stories delivered to your inbox.
Subscribe
More in Family Sponsorship
Are you eligible to sponsor your spouse or partner for Canadian immigration?
A couple sitting at a laptop considering their sponsorship options
How can my parents and grandparents join me in Canada?
A picture of a man and his mother smiling.
Sponsoring your spouse or partner for Canadian immigration
Happy couple reuniting at an airport
How does IRCC choose sponsors through the Parents and Grandparents Program?
A man and his elderly father walking in a garden on a summer day.
Link copied to clipboard